Skip to main content

Suing the City, NYCHA or the MTA: What Public Agencies Pay and How Long It Takes

By Nico SteelePublished · 4 min read

The Manhattan Municipal Building, which houses New York City offices

If a City vehicle, a City street, a NYCHA building or a subway or bus hurt you, your claim is against a public agency. Here is what those agencies typically pay, how long it takes, and the deadlines you have to meet.

The numbers

SettleScore looked at injury payments and resolved cases against public agencies in New York, from City payment records, court decisions and news reports. The chart below shows how long a claim typically took to resolve, from the claim or lawsuit to payment, for the biggest public defendants.

Bar chart of the typical time to resolve an injury claim, by public defendant: Department of Correction 11 months; NYPD 19 months; City of New York, all agencies, 2.1 years; NYCHA 3.1 years; Department of Transportation 3.2 years; NYC Health + Hospitals 3.2 years; MTA and NYC Transit 4.3 years.

NYCHA, the MTA and other public agencies

Who was suedPaymentsTypical paymentTypical time to resolve
NYCHA880$55,0003.1 years
MTA and NYC Transit1,020$50,0004.3 years
State of New York107$65,0002.9 years
Port Authority49$75,0003.7 years
Other cities, towns and counties69$310,0003.2 years
Other public agencies84$57,5003.6 years

New York City agencies

Who was suedPaymentsTypical paymentTypical time to resolve
City of New York, all agencies91,171$25,0002.1 years
NYPD35,647$20,00019 months
Department of Correction11,529$8,00011 months
Department of Transportation8,921$35,0003.2 years
Department of Education6,256$45,0003.1 years
Department of Sanitation3,375$60,0002.7 years
Parks & Recreation3,022$50,0002.8 years
FDNY2,594$45,0002.6 years
NYC Health + Hospitals1,013$175,0003.2 years
Environmental Protection902$50,0003 years
Housing Preservation & Development149$82,5003.6 years
Homeless Services138$30,0002.3 years
Administration for Children's Services95$60,0002.9 years

A case that names two agencies counts under each here, so these counts are a little higher than in our guide to what New York City pays for injury claims, which counts each payment once.

Why payments differ so much

Police and jail claims make up about half of the City's payments, and they are typically small: $20,000 for the NYPD and $8,000 for the Department of Correction. Many are civil-rights claims, such as false arrest. Claims against NYC Health + Hospitals, the City's public hospitals, typically paid $175,000.

The deadlines are short

Claims against public agencies run on a much shorter clock than the usual three years.

  • New York City, NYCHA, NYC Health + Hospitals and NYC Transit: a notice of claim, a short sworn form, must be served within 90 days. The lawsuit must generally be filed within 1 year and 90 days, or within 2 years of a death in a wrongful death case. City claims go to the City Comptroller, but claims against NYCHA, NYC Health + Hospitals and NYC Transit go to that agency directly.
  • New York State: claims go to the New York State Court of Claims. A claim for an injury caused by carelessness must be filed, or a notice of intention served, within 90 days.
  • The Port Authority: a notice of claim must be served at least 60 days before you sue, and the lawsuit must be filed within one year.

Our notice of claim guide explains which agency to serve and how.

What to do if a public agency hurt you

  • Get medical care, and keep your records.
  • Write down exactly where and when it happened, and photograph the spot, such as the broken sidewalk, the bus or the stairwell.
  • Find out which agency is responsible. Buses and buildings that look alike can belong to different agencies.
  • Serve the notice of claim within 90 days, and keep proof that you did.
  • Know what cases like yours recover. Our guides to subway, bus and train cases and falls show what they have recovered.

How to read these numbers

  • The time to resolve runs from when the claim or lawsuit was filed until it was paid or otherwise resolved. Only resolved cases are counted.
  • The payments come from public records, including the City's payment records, court decisions and news reports. The figures are as of November 13, 2026.
  • A typical payment is the middle amount: half of the payments were higher, and half lower.

This article gives general information about New York law. It is not legal advice. Talk with a New York injury lawyer about your own case.

Sources

Was this guide helpful?

← Back to Case value