What Is a Construction Accident Case Worth in NYC?
By Nico SteelePublished · 5 min read

New York's Scaffold Law makes property owners and contractors responsible for many falls on construction sites, even when the worker was also careless. Here is what construction cases have recovered in New York City, and what to do if you were hurt on a job site.
The numbers
The typical construction accident case recovered $2.1 million. That means half of the cases recovered more, and half recovered less.
About 7 out of 10 cases recovered between $1 million and $10 million. More than 3 out of 4 recovered $1 million or more.
The chart below shows how many construction accident cases recovered each amount. Each bar is a range of dollar amounts, and the longer the bar, the more cases ended in that range. The gold bar is the range where the typical case falls.
These figures come from 2,904 construction accident wins that New York City law firms list on their websites. Each amount is the total the case recovered, before the lawyer's fee and other costs come out.
Why construction cases are worth so much
The chart below compares the typical recovery for seven common kinds of injury cases, from highest to lowest. Construction accidents are in gold.
The Scaffold Law puts the responsibility on owners and contractors
New York Labor Law § 240(1), known as the Scaffold Law, requires property owners and contractors to protect workers from falls and falling objects, with safe scaffolds, ladders, harnesses, hoists and similar equipment. If they don't, and that failure helps cause your injury, they are responsible for it.
Under this law, the worker's own carelessness isn't a defense for the owner or contractor, as New York's highest court has held. You still have to show that the missing or unsafe equipment helped cause the injury, and not every accident on a job site falls under this law.
You sue the owner and contractor, not your employer
In New York, workers' compensation is generally the only thing you can get from your own employer. So the lawsuit is brought against others connected to the job, such as the property owner and the general contractor.
The injuries are severe, and so are the lost wages
Falls from scaffolds, ladders and roofs can cause broken bones, spine injuries and brain injuries, and an injury that ends a career can cost years of future pay. Even construction cases that name a soft-tissue injury, such as a sprain or strain, typically recovered $1.75 million. In crash cases, the same kind of injury typically recovered $300,000.
Injuries that raise the value
Here is what construction cases in our records typically recovered, by the injury they name.
| Injury | Typical recovery |
|---|---|
| Sprain, strain or other soft-tissue injury | $1.75 million |
| Broken bone | $1.75 million |
| Any injury that needed surgery | $2 million |
| Spinal fusion surgery | $2.85 million |
| Death | $3 million |
| Traumatic brain injury | $3.5 million |
| Spinal cord injury or paralysis | $12 million |
What to do if you were hurt on a job site
- Tell your employer about the injury in writing within 30 days.
- File a workers' compensation claim with the Workers' Compensation Board within two years. Workers' comp pays your medical care, and if you miss more than seven days of work, part of your wages.
- Write down what happened while you remember it: where you were working, what equipment you had, who was in charge and who saw the accident. Take photos if you can.
- Know your lawsuit deadline. Most injury lawsuits in New York must be filed within three years. If the job was for the City or another public agency, you may have only 90 days to file a notice of claim, a short form that tells the agency you plan to sue.
- Compare lawyers by their results. SettleScore's NYC construction accident rankings rank firms by the construction cases they have won. Firms can't pay to rank higher.
What can lower a case's value
A key question in a construction case is whether the Scaffold Law applies. A fall from a ladder or scaffold usually involves the kind of height risk it covers. A trip over debris on the ground usually doesn't, although other safety rules and general negligence law may still apply.
When the Scaffold Law doesn't apply, your share of the blame can matter. New York still uses "pure comparative fault" for construction accidents: if you were partly to blame, your recovery goes down by your share, but it is never wiped out. The stricter 2026 rule that bars people more to blame than those they sue applies only to motor vehicle cases under New York's no-fault law.
How to read these numbers
- Law firms choose which wins to list, so these figures likely run higher than what most cases recover.
- The amounts are what the case recovered in total. The lawyer's fee, case costs and repayment to the workers' compensation insurer come out first. SettleScore's settlement calculator includes a workers' comp repayment.
- Each law firm has an office in New York City, but the accident may have happened somewhere else.
This article gives general information about New York law and recoveries published by law firms. It is not legal advice. Talk with a New York injury lawyer about your own case.
Sources
- Recoveries: SettleScore's records of settlements and verdicts published by law firms with a New York City office, as of November 14, 2026: 2,938 construction accident recoveries from 242 firms, 2,904 of them with an exact amount. The middle half of those 2,904 fell between $1 million and $3.6 million. Injury figures: SettleScore's records of recoveries that name the injury, as of November 13, 2026. See how SettleScore works.
- Scaffold Law: New York Court of Appeals, Blake v Neighborhood Housing Services of New York City (2003).
- Employer immunity: New York Workers' Compensation Law § 11.
- Workers' compensation benefits and deadlines: New York State Workers' Compensation Board, Injured Worker's Toolkit.
- Comparative fault: CPLR 1411, including the 2026 rule for lawsuits under the no-fault law in subdivision (b).
- Deadlines: CPLR 214 and General Municipal Law § 50-e.
Compare Firms Handling Cases Like These
The top-ranked firms by SettleScore on their documented construction accident results. Firms can't pay to rank higher.
#1 Sacks & Sacks, LLP
ManhattanSettleScore 98 out of 10096 case results
#2 Block O'Toole & Murphy, LLP
ManhattanSettleScore 97 out of 10083 case results
#3 Zaremba Brown PLLC
ManhattanSettleScore 97 out of 10097 case results


