What Is a Medical Malpractice Case Worth in NYC?
By Nico SteelePublished · 4 min read

A medical malpractice case needs a doctor's review before it is filed, has its own deadlines, and limits the lawyer's fee. Here is what these cases have recovered in New York City, and what to do if you think a medical mistake hurt you.
The numbers
The typical medical malpractice case recovered $1.5 million. That means half of the cases recovered more, and half recovered less.
About 7 out of 10 cases recovered $1 million or more. Almost none recovered under $100,000.
The chart below shows how many medical malpractice cases recovered each amount. Each bar is a range of dollar amounts, and the longer the bar, the more cases ended in that range. The gold bar is the range where the typical case falls.
These figures come from 1,480 medical malpractice wins that New York City law firms list on their websites. Each amount is the total the case recovered, before the lawyer's fee and other costs come out.
Why malpractice cases recover so much
The chart below compares the typical recovery for seven common kinds of injury cases, from highest to lowest. Medical malpractice cases are in gold.
Serious harm recovers the most
In our records, the malpractice cases that recovered the most name serious harm, such as spinal cord injuries, brain injuries and injuries to babies at birth.
You have to prove two things
It isn't enough that a treatment didn't work. You generally have to show that the doctor, nurse or hospital made a mistake that a careful provider in the same field wouldn't have made, and that the mistake caused your harm. Both generally take testimony from medical experts. Before filing, the lawyer generally must certify that they consulted a doctor and that the case has a reasonable basis.
Injuries that raise the value
The injury makes a big difference. Here is what malpractice cases in our records typically recovered, by the injury they name.
| Injury | Typical recovery |
|---|---|
| Death | $1.5 million |
| Harm to an internal organ | $1.5 million |
| Loss of vision or hearing | $1.5 million |
| Amputation | $2.6 million |
| Injury to a baby at birth | $3.65 million |
| Traumatic brain injury | $4.55 million |
| Spinal cord injury or paralysis | $4.62 million |
How New York limits the lawyer's fee
In other injury cases, the lawyer's fee can be a third of the recovery. In malpractice cases, New York law sets a lower, sliding limit:
| Part of the recovery | Highest fee |
|---|---|
| First $250,000 | 30% |
| Next $250,000 | 25% |
| Next $500,000 | 20% |
| Next $250,000 | 15% |
| Anything over $1.25 million | 10% |
The fee is figured on what is left after case costs. On $1.5 million left after costs, the fee can be no more than $300,000, or 20%. A one-third fee would be $500,000.
What to do if you think a medical mistake hurt you
- Get copies of your medical records. You have a right to them.
- Keep getting the care you need, from another provider if you prefer.
- Know your deadline. You generally have two years and six months from the mistake to sue. If you kept getting treatment for the same problem from the same provider, the clock usually starts at the last treatment. Other rules apply to an object left in your body and to a missed cancer diagnosis.
- If the care was at a City hospital run by NYC Health + Hospitals, you usually have only 90 days to file a notice of claim, a short form that tells the hospital system you plan to sue, and one year and 90 days to file the lawsuit. Our notice of claim guide explains how.
- Compare lawyers by their results. SettleScore's NYC medical malpractice rankings rank firms by the malpractice cases they have won. Firms can't pay to rank higher.
How to read these numbers
- Law firms choose which wins to list, so these figures likely run higher than what most cases recover. The City of New York's own records show how wide the gap can be: across 1,058 malpractice claims the City paid, the typical payment was $225,000.
- The amounts are what the case recovered in total. The lawyer's fee, case costs and medical bills that must be paid back come out first. SettleScore's settlement calculator uses the malpractice fee limits.
- Each law firm has an office in New York City, but the care may have happened somewhere else.
This article gives general information about New York law and recoveries published by law firms. It is not legal advice. Talk with a New York injury lawyer about your own case.
Sources
- Recoveries: SettleScore's records of settlements and verdicts published by law firms with a New York City office, as of November 14, 2026: 1,535 medical malpractice recoveries from 169 firms, 1,480 of them with an exact amount. The middle half of those 1,480 fell between $850,000 and $3.25 million. Injury figures: SettleScore's records of recoveries that name the injury, as of November 13, 2026. See how SettleScore works.
- City payments: City of New York payment records, as summarized in What New York City Pays for Injury Claims (the "Medical malpractice" row; 1,058 payments).
- Fee limits: New York Judiciary Law § 474-a. The one-third fee in other injury cases: 22 NYCRR 603.25(e).
- Certificate of merit: CPLR 3012-a.
- Deadlines: CPLR 214-a and General Municipal Law § 50-e. NYC Health + Hospitals: New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation Act § 20.
Compare Firms Handling Cases Like These
The top-ranked firms by SettleScore on their documented medical malpractice results. Firms can't pay to rank higher.
#1 Kramer, Dillof, Livingston & Moore, LLP
ManhattanSettleScore 98 out of 10062 case results
#2 Torgan Cooper + Aaron
ManhattanSettleScore 93 out of 10030 case results
#3 Sanocki Newman & Turret, LLP
ManhattanSettleScore 90 out of 10065 case results


