Skip to main content

What Is a Slip and Fall Case Worth in NYC?

By Nico SteelePublished · 5 min read

A caution wet floor sign on a wet walkway

In a fall case, you generally have to show that the property owner created the danger, knew about it or should have known about it. Here is what these cases have recovered in New York City, who is responsible, and what to do after a fall.

The numbers

The typical slip and fall case recovered $650,000. That means half of the cases recovered more, and half recovered less.

About 4 out of 5 cases recovered between $150,000 and $3 million. About 1 in 3 recovered $1 million or more.

The chart below shows how many slip and fall cases recovered each amount. Each bar is a range of dollar amounts, and the longer the bar, the more cases ended in that range. The gold bar is the range where the typical case falls.

Bar chart of 2,199 slip and fall cases by amount recovered: 7 under $25,000; 37 from $25,000 to $75,000; 136 from $75,000 to $150,000; 489 from $150,000 to $350,000; 737 from $350,000 to $1 million, where the typical case falls at $650,000; 580 from $1 million to $3 million; 182 from $3 million to $10 million; 31 at $10 million or more.

These figures come from 2,199 slip and fall wins that New York City law firms list on their websites. They include trips, falls on stairs and other injuries caused by unsafe property. Each amount is the total the case recovered, before the lawyer's fee and other costs come out.

Why fall cases recover less than many others

The chart below compares the typical recovery for seven common kinds of injury cases, from highest to lowest. Slip and fall cases are in gold.

Bar chart of the typical amount recovered by type of case: construction accident $2.1 million, wrongful death $2 million, medical malpractice $1.5 million, truck accident $1.2 million, pedestrian accident $950,000, car accident $820,000, slip and fall $650,000.

You have to prove the owner knew about the danger

A fall on someone's property isn't automatically their fault. You generally have to show that the owner created the danger, knew about it, or should have known about it. Under New York's rule, an owner "should have known" when the danger was visible and had been there long enough that the owner's staff could have found and fixed it. A spill that happened seconds before you fell may not meet that test. A visible broken step that was there for months likely does.

The owner may say you should have watched your step

The owner may argue the hazard was easy to see. In a fall case, being partly to blame doesn't stop you from recovering, but it lowers your recovery by your share. For example, if you were 25% to blame, you get 75%.

Broken bones recover less in fall cases

A fall can cause serious harm, such as a broken hip or a head injury. But in our records, broken bones recover less in fall cases than in crash cases. A broken bone typically recovered $360,000 in fall and other property cases, compared with $750,000 in vehicle crash cases. A broken bone that needed surgery typically recovered $500,000, compared with $815,000.

Injuries that raise the value

The injury makes a big difference. Here is what fall and other property injury cases in our records typically recovered, by the injury they name.

InjuryTypical recovery
Sprain, strain or other soft-tissue injury$320,000
Broken bone$360,000
Broken bone that needed surgery$500,000
Any injury that needed surgery$600,000
Spinal fusion surgery$1.29 million
Traumatic brain injury$1.68 million
Death$2 million

Who is responsible in New York City

  • Stores, offices and apartment buildings: the owner, or a tenant or company that controls or maintains the property.
  • Sidewalks: City law makes the owner of the property next to a sidewalk responsible for keeping it in repair, and that owner can be held responsible for injuries caused by a broken sidewalk. The exception is a one-, two- or three-family house that the owner lives in and uses only as a home. There, the responsibility stays with the City.
  • Streets, City buildings and parks: the City. You usually have only 90 days to file a notice of claim, a short form that tells the City you plan to sue, and one year and 90 days to sue. Our look at what the City pays for injury claims shows how these claims turn out.

What to do after a fall

  • Get medical care right away, and tell the doctor exactly how you fell.
  • Take photos of the spot that caused the fall, from close up and from farther away, before anything changes. Keep the shoes you were wearing.
  • Report the fall to the store, landlord or building manager, and ask for a copy of any incident report.
  • Get the names and phone numbers of anyone who saw it.
  • Know your deadline. Most injury lawsuits in New York must be filed within three years. On City property, the notice of claim is due in 90 days.
  • Compare lawyers by their results. SettleScore's NYC rankings for falls and property injuries rank firms by the fall cases they have won. Firms can't pay to rank higher.

How to read these numbers

  • Law firms choose which wins to list, so these figures likely run higher than what most cases recover. The City of New York's own records show how wide the gap can be: across 6,998 property injury claims the City paid, the typical payment was $30,000.
  • The amounts are what the case recovered in total. The lawyer's fee, case costs and medical bills that must be paid back come out first. SettleScore's settlement calculator shows what you would keep.
  • Each law firm has an office in New York City, but the fall may have happened somewhere else.

This article gives general information about New York law and recoveries published by law firms. It is not legal advice. Talk with a New York injury lawyer about your own case.

Sources

  • Recoveries: SettleScore's records of settlements and verdicts published by law firms with a New York City office, as of November 14, 2026: 2,230 fall and property injury recoveries from 251 firms, 2,199 of them with an exact amount. The middle half of those 2,199 fell between $285,000 and $1.5 million. Injury figures: SettleScore's records of recoveries that name the injury, as of November 13, 2026. See how SettleScore works.
  • City payments: City of New York payment records, as summarized in What New York City Pays for Injury Claims (the "Falls and property conditions" row; 6,998 payments).
  • When an owner should have known: New York Court of Appeals, Gordon v American Museum of Natural History (1986).
  • Sidewalks: New York City Department of Transportation, Sidewalks (Administrative Code §§ 19-152 and 7-210). The exception for owner-occupied homes: Appellate Division, Second Department, Giuntini v City of New York (2024).
  • Comparative fault: CPLR 1411.
  • Deadlines: CPLR 214, General Municipal Law § 50-e (notice of claim) and § 50-i (lawsuits against the City).

Compare Firms Handling Cases Like These

The top-ranked firms by SettleScore on their documented falls and property injury results. Firms can't pay to rank higher.

  1. #1 Subin Associates, LLP

    ManhattanSettleScore 97 out of 10032 case results

  2. #2 Block O'Toole & Murphy, LLP

    ManhattanSettleScore 96 out of 10033 case results

  3. #3 Lipsig, Freund & Wisell, PLLC

    ManhattanSettleScore 94 out of 10028 case results

See the full ranking

Was this guide helpful?

← Back to Case value