Skip to main content

Methodology

The research behind our rankings

How we collect and compare New York personal injury firm results, where each claim comes from, and what the evidence does—and doesn’t—show.

5results needed for a SettleScore
2×weight of a court or government record versus a result a firm publishes
0paid inputs in the ranking calculation
4source tiers: court, government, press, firm-published

The personal injury market in New York is notoriously difficult to navigate. Marketing claims often obscure context, and "results" pages on law firm websites can be difficult to compare. SettleScore combines what firms publish with public court and government records, keeps the source of every result, and gives independent records more weight than results firms report about themselves.

Data Collection

We combine results firms publish on their own websites with public records: court decisions, NYC government records, and press reports that name the firm as the injured person's lawyers.

Source preservation

Every number in the directory must have a citation. Firm-published results are kept as reported claims rather than upgraded into independently verified outcomes.

Evidence Tiers

Every result is labeled by its source, and the source sets how much the result counts in the SettleScore.

Objective Presentation

Payment never changes rankings. The directory rankings are strictly merit-based.

Where each result comes from

Every result on SettleScore is labeled with where it comes from. You will see one of these four labels next to each result:

  • Court record: From a court decision or other court filing.
  • Government record: From New York City government records, such as city settlements paid by the Comptroller or the Law Department.
  • Press report: From a news article that names the firm as the injured person's lawyers.
  • Firm-published: The firm reported this result on its own website. We have not confirmed it in court records or the news.
Note: Tiers measure source support and objective evidence existence, not law-firm quality or predicted outcomes for future cases.

How the SettleScore works

Each firm with at least 5 results receives a SettleScore from 0 to 100. It places the firm among ranked New York firms on two equal parts:

  • Volume (50%): How many results the firm has, each weighted by its source: a court or government record counts 1, a press report 0.75, and a result the firm publishes about itself 0.5. The firm's count in each case type is compared with the average among firms on SettleScore with results in that case type, so case types where firms handle more cases give no advantage. Volume is measured on a logarithmic scale, so each doubling adds the same amount and there is no cap.
  • Result size (50%): How large the firm's results are compared with results of the same case type on SettleScore. Each result with an exact amount is ranked among all results of its case type: a car accident result larger than 80% of the car accident results on SettleScore counts as 80. The firm's size is the average of those ranks, using the same source weights. A firm gains nothing from handling case types that pay more, one very large verdict can't carry a firm, and firms with only a few results are pulled toward the middle until there is more evidence.

Each part is converted to a percentile among ranked firms: a percentile of 90 means the firm is ahead of 90% of ranked firms on that part. The SettleScore is the average of the two percentiles.

For example, a firm ahead of 90% of firms on volume but in the middle (50%) on result size scores (90 + 50) ÷ 2 = 70. Because a high score needs strength on both parts, high scores are rarer than the number suggests. Right now, about 10% of ranked firms score 80 or more.

Lawsuits against the City of New York from NYC Law Department records don't state a case type, so they form their own case type, Cases against NYC, and are compared only with each other. A few court decisions with no case type count toward no score.

Most results on SettleScore are published by the firms themselves. The SettleScore compares firms with each other on the results we have; it does not say what is normal for a case type or what any case is worth.

Every case counts once. When a firm publishes a result that also appears in court or government records, we count the public record. Claims brought by insurers or medical providers, such as an insurer recovering what it paid, are not injury cases and never count.

A firm needs at least 5 results, published or from public records, to be scored. Firms below that threshold stay in the directory and show "Not rated."

A firm's paid plan, advertising, and reviews are never part of the score.

What the scores mean

The SettleScore compares firms with each other. It is not a school grade, where 70 is passing. It shows how a firm's record of results compares with other ranked New York firms. The shares below come from the current rankings and update as results are added.

90–100

Top of the fieldAbout the top 3% of ranked firms

One of the strongest records in New York. These firms have many results on record, and their results are large for their case types.

80–89

Very strong80 or more: about the top 10%

Well ahead of most firms. Usually strong on both the number of results and their size, or outstanding on one of them.

70–79

Strong70 or more: about the top 17%

Clearly above average, with a solid number of results that are good-sized for their case types.

60–69

Above average60 or more: about the top 29%

Ahead of most ranked firms on the combination of how many results they have and how large those results are.

50–59

Average50 or more: about the top 51%

Around the middle of ranked New York firms.

0–49

Smaller record on fileAbout 49% of ranked firms

Fewer results on record, results that are smaller for their case types, or both, compared with other ranked firms. This is not a rating of the lawyers' skill: smaller and newer firms often score here.

—

Not rated

Fewer than 5 results on record, so there is not enough evidence to score the firm yet. It says nothing about the firm's quality.

Case-type scores on a firm's profile use the same scale, but compare the firm only with other firms' results in that type of case.

How to use the score

  • Look at the score for your type of case. A firm's profile shows its case-type scores, such as car accidents or construction.
  • Small differences don't mean much. Two firms scoring 78 and 81 have similar records, so compare their results instead.
  • Read the results on the firm's profile. Look for cases like yours, and check where each result comes from.
  • Talk to more than one firm. Many injury lawyers offer a free first consultation.
  • The score is about a firm's past results. It cannot tell you what your case is worth.

How We Rank Firms

Every ranking, borough page, and case-type page on SettleScore orders firms by the SettleScore described above, highest first.

  1. Overall and location rankings: Use each firm's SettleScore across all of its results. A borough or region lists firms with a verified office there; their cases did not necessarily happen in that place.
  2. Case-type rankings: Use a SettleScore calculated only from the firm's results in that case type, so medical-malpractice results never rank a firm for pedestrian accidents. A firm needs at least 5 results in the case type to be ranked in it.
  3. Ties: Firms with the same displayed score are ordered by their unrounded score, then by number of results.
  4. Not rated: Firms with fewer than 5 results get no SettleScore and no rank. Borough and case-type pages still list them, after every ranked firm, marked “Not rated.”
  5. No paid inputs: A firm's plan, advertising, and reviews never change its score or its position.

For Law Firms

We do not offer "premium profiles" to boost ranking visibility. If you are a law firm and wish to update your profile, you may claim your profile and submit verifiable court documents or press links to our editorial team. We will review the submissions and, if verified, update the public record accordingly.

Disclaimer

The information provided on this site is for research and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. The data presented may be incomplete or outdated as new information becomes available. Always consult directly with a qualified attorney regarding your specific legal situation.