Skip to main content

What Is a Car Accident Case Worth in NYC?

By Nico SteelePublished · 5 min read

Yellow taxis and delivery trucks in Manhattan traffic

What a car accident case is worth in New York depends on how badly you were hurt, whether the injury meets the state's "serious injury" test, and how much insurance the other driver has. Here is what these cases have recovered in New York City, and what to do after a crash.

The numbers

The typical car accident case recovered $820,000. That means half of the cases recovered more, and half recovered less.

Car cases vary more than most. About 7 out of 10 recovered between $150,000 and $3 million. Some recovered much less: about 1 in 9 recovered under $100,000.

The chart below shows how many car accident cases recovered each amount. Each bar is a range of dollar amounts, and the longer the bar, the more cases ended in that range. The gold bar is the range where the typical case falls.

Bar chart of 2,859 car accident cases by amount recovered: 77 under $25,000; 151 from $25,000 to $75,000; 252 from $75,000 to $150,000; 395 from $150,000 to $350,000; 738 from $350,000 to $1 million, where the typical case falls at $820,000; 912 from $1 million to $3 million; 275 from $3 million to $10 million; 59 at $10 million or more.

These figures come from 2,859 car accident wins that New York City law firms list on their websites. Each amount is the total the case recovered, before the lawyer's fee and other costs come out.

Why car cases vary so much

A car case can be about a sore neck after a fender bender or a brain injury after a highway crash. New York's no-fault system and insurance limits shape what each kind of case can recover.

The chart below compares the typical recovery for seven common kinds of injury cases, from highest to lowest. Car accidents are in gold.

Bar chart of the typical amount recovered by type of case: construction accident $2.1 million, wrongful death $2 million, medical malpractice $1.5 million, truck accident $1.2 million, pedestrian accident $950,000, car accident $820,000, slip and fall $650,000.

No-fault pays the first bills

After a crash, no-fault insurance pays your medical bills and 80% of your lost pay, up to $2,000 a month, up to a total of $50,000. It pays no matter who caused the crash. So a car case is mostly about what no-fault doesn't cover, above all pain and suffering. No-fault doesn't cover people hurt while riding a motorcycle.

Pain and suffering needs a "serious injury"

To get money for pain and suffering from the other driver, your injury has to meet New York's "serious injury" test. A broken bone counts. So does significant disfigurement, or a significant or permanent limitation in how part of your body works. Our serious injury guide shows how often claims fail the test on appeal.

Insurance limits set a ceiling

The other driver's insurance pays only up to its limit. New York drivers only need $25,000 of coverage for one injured person, and $50,000 for everyone hurt in one crash. If the other driver has only the minimum, a serious case can end at that limit.

Your own policy may help. Supplementary uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, called SUM, is optional coverage that pays you after the other driver's insurance runs out, if their limits are lower than yours. It covers you and relatives who live with you.

Injuries that raise the value

The injury makes a big difference. Here is what crash cases in our records typically recovered, by the injury they name. These cover car, truck and pedestrian crashes together.

InjuryTypical recovery
Sprain, strain or other soft-tissue injury$300,000
Herniated disc that needed surgery$562,500
Broken bone$750,000
Broken bone that needed surgery$815,000
Spinal fusion surgery$1.05 million
Traumatic brain injury$2.25 million

What to do after a car crash

  • Get medical care, and keep going to your appointments. Gaps in treatment give the insurer a reason to say you weren't badly hurt.
  • File for no-fault quickly. Give the insurer written notice within 30 days of the crash, and send medical bills within 45 days of treatment. Our car accident timeline guide covers these deadlines.
  • Check your own policy for SUM coverage.
  • Know your lawsuit deadline. Most injury lawsuits in New York must be filed within three years. If a City vehicle hit you, you usually have only 90 days to file a notice of claim, a short form that tells the City you plan to sue.
  • Compare lawyers by their results. SettleScore's NYC car accident rankings rank firms by the car accident cases they have won. Firms can't pay to rank higher.

Rules that can lower a case's value

For most car crash lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026, if you were more to blame than the people you are suing, you can't recover damages from them. Otherwise, your recovery goes down by your share. For example, if you were 20% to blame, you get 80%.

Two more changes apply to lawsuits filed since then. Being kept from your usual activities for 90 of the first 180 days was removed from the list of "serious injuries." And a driver who was partly at fault can get no more than $100,000 for pain and suffering if they were driving uninsured, or were convicted of impaired driving or of a felony committed while driving. A coverage lapse of less than 30 days doesn't count as driving uninsured.

How to read these numbers

  • Law firms choose which wins to list, so these figures likely run higher than what most cases recover. The City of New York's own records show how wide the gap can be: across 4,689 crash claims the City paid, the typical payment was $40,000.
  • The amounts are what the case recovered in total. The lawyer's fee, case costs and medical bills that must be paid back come out first. SettleScore's settlement calculator shows what you would keep.
  • Each law firm has an office in New York City, but the crash may have happened somewhere else.

This article gives general information about New York law and recoveries published by law firms. It is not legal advice. Talk with a New York injury lawyer about your own case.

Sources

Compare Firms Handling Cases Like These

The top-ranked firms by SettleScore on their documented car accident results. Firms can't pay to rank higher.

  1. #1 Block O'Toole & Murphy, LLP

    ManhattanSettleScore 99 out of 10084 case results

  2. #2 Subin Associates, LLP

    ManhattanSettleScore 98 out of 10064 case results

  3. #3 Torgan Cooper + Aaron

    ManhattanSettleScore 95 out of 10037 case results

See the full ranking

Was this guide helpful?

← Back to Case value