Hurt on a City Bus? You Have 90 Days, Not Three Years
By Nico SteelePublished · 6 min read

Most New Yorkers have heard that you get three years to sue over an injury. That is true when a private driver hits you. It is dangerously wrong when a city bus does.
Claims against public agencies run on a much shorter clock, and the first deadline arrives in 90 days. Miss it and your case can be over before you have finished physical therapy.
Two deadlines, not one
| Step | Deadline | What happens if you miss it |
|---|---|---|
| Serve a notice of claim | 90 days from the date of the incident | You generally cannot sue without a judge's permission |
| File the lawsuit | 1 year and 90 days from the incident | The case is time-barred |
Between those two there is usually a third step, a sworn examination, covered below. The rules also differ by agency, as the next table shows, so confirm the rule for the agency involved in your case.
Who you serve depends on who owned the bus
This trips people up, because buses that look alike can belong to different agencies. A notice served on the wrong agency generally does not count as notice to the right one.
| If the vehicle was | Serve the notice on | Deadline to sue |
|---|---|---|
| A New York City Transit bus or the subway | New York City Transit Authority, directly | 1 year and 90 days |
| An MTA Bus Company bus or another MTA agency | That agency itself, not the City (see below) | 1 year and 90 days |
| A City vehicle, or a City sidewalk, park or school | The NYC Comptroller's Office | 1 year and 90 days |
| A school bus | Depends. The Department of Education requires a notice of claim; a private bus company on its own does not | 90 days and 1 year 90 days against the DOE; generally 3 years against a private company alone |
| A private car, truck or bus | Nobody | Generally 3 years |
The Comptroller's Office says plainly that claims against the MTA, New York City Transit, MaBSTOA (the Manhattan and Bronx Surface Transit Operating Authority), MTA Bus Company, NYCHA and NYC Health + Hospitals must be served on that agency itself, not through the Comptroller.
MTA Bus Company runs local and express routes in the Bronx, Brooklyn and Queens. Courts have held that it and other MTA subsidiaries, such as the Long Island Rail Road, do not require a formal notice of claim. You must still give them a written demand for payment at least 30 days before you sue, and the 1 year and 90 days limit still applies.
School buses are their own puzzle. Most are run by private companies under contract to the Department of Education. A claim that names the DOE needs a notice of claim; one against the bus company alone usually does not.
If you are not certain who operated the vehicle, the safe move is to serve everyone who might be responsible inside the 90 days and sort it out afterward.
What the notice has to contain
State law sets out what goes in it. The notice must be in writing, sworn to, and include:
- Your name and mailing address, and your lawyer's if you have one
- The nature of the claim
- When, where and how it happened
- The injuries and losses you are claiming
"Where" means specific. A bus stop, an intersection, a direction of travel, a bus route and a time. A vague location is one of the most common ways a notice gets challenged later.
How to file it
For claims against the City, the Comptroller's Office accepts a notice of claim three ways:
- Online through its eClaim system
- By registered or certified mail
- In person at the office
For Transit and the MTA, the notice goes to that authority rather than the Comptroller. NYC Transit posts its own personal injury claim form on the MTA website for claims involving NYC Transit and MaBSTOA, and the form says to email it within 90 days of the incident. Whichever route you use, keep proof: the certified mail receipt, the eClaim confirmation, or the stamped copy.
The hearing before the lawsuit
After the notice is filed, the agency can require you to answer questions under oath before any lawsuit begins. Against the City this is the 50-h hearing named for the statute that creates it. The Transit Authority and the MTA have a similar power under their own laws to make you answer questions under oath about a claim. What to know:
- It usually happens before any lawsuit is filed.
- If the City demands a 50-h hearing and you do not appear, you generally cannot start your case.
- You must also wait at least 30 days after serving the notice before you can file a lawsuit.
- A lawyer for the agency will ask about the incident, your injuries and your treatment.
- The transcript follows the case to the end, so what you say there matters later.
The City's own process runs alongside this. The Comptroller investigates and can settle before a lawsuit is filed, but that window closes once a suit begins or once one year and ninety days have run.
If the 90 days already passed
It is not automatically over, but you need a judge.
- A court can allow a late notice, and must consider whether the agency already knew the essential facts within the 90 days or soon after.
- It also weighs whether the delay hurt the agency's ability to defend itself, whether you made an honest mistake about which agency to serve, and circumstances like the claimant being a child or seriously incapacitated.
- Permission can only be granted up to the deadline for starting the lawsuit, usually 1 year and 90 days, so every week of delay leaves less time.
- This is not a do-it-yourself motion. If you are past 90 days, talk to a lawyer as soon as you can.
What to do in the first week
- Write down the route number, bus number, direction, time and exact location while you still remember them.
- Photograph the scene, the vehicle and your injuries.
- Get the names of witnesses, including other passengers.
- Report it and get medical attention, even if you feel able to walk away, and ask for the incident report number.
- Start the 90-day clock in your calendar the same day.
Why the short deadline exists
Public agencies argue that they need to investigate while evidence is fresh, and they handle a very large number of claims. The Comptroller's report for fiscal 2023 counted 18,895 personal injury claims filed against the City. Personal injury claims made up $733.3 million, or 99%, of the $739.6 million the City paid that year on injury and property damage claims. Whatever the reason for the rule, the person who was hurt gets far less time to decide what to do, so it helps to know about the 90-day deadline before you need it.
If you need help identifying counsel quickly, search New York injury firms and ask directly about the agency-specific notice deadline.
This article is general information about New York law, not legal advice for your situation.
Sources: General Municipal Law 50-e · General Municipal Law 50-h · General Municipal Law 50-i · Public Authorities Law 1212 · Public Authorities Law 1276 · NYC Comptroller, file a claim · NYC Comptroller, personal injury claim FAQs · CPLR 214 · NYC Comptroller, annual claims report (FY2023) · NYC Transit personal injury claim form · MTA Bus Company · Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. v MTA Bus Co. (2015) · Matter of Rodriguez v Metropolitan Transp. Auth. (1st Dept 2017)
Compare Firms Handling Cases Like These
The top-ranked firms by SettleScore on their documented subway, bus, and train accident results. Firms can't pay to rank higher.
#1 Lipsig, Freund & Wisell, PLLC
ManhattanSettleScore 100 out of 10010 case results
#2 Kelner & Kelner
ManhattanSettleScore 88 out of 1007 case results
#3 Hecht, Kleeger & Damashek, P.C.
ManhattanSettleScore 75 out of 1005 case results


