What Is My Injury Worth? Typical New York Recoveries by Injury
By Nico SteelePublished · 4 min read

If you were hurt, one of the first questions is what your injury is worth. Here is what New York injury cases typically recovered, by the injury they describe, and how to use the numbers for your own case.
The numbers
SettleScore looked at 5,180 New York recoveries that describe the injury. The chart below shows the typical recovery for nine common injuries, from lowest to highest. The typical recovery is the middle amount: half of the cases recovered more, and half recovered less.
Every injury in our records
The table below lists every injury with at least 20 recoveries. The last column shows the typical recovery from public records alone, such as court decisions and government records, where there are at least 20 of them. Law firms choose which of their own wins to publish, so public records are a useful check.
| Injury | Typical recovery | Half were between | Recoveries | Public records only |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spinal cord injury or paralysis | $5.68 million | $3 million to $15.5 million | 106 | Too few |
| Birth injury | $3.78 million | $1.96 million to $6.85 million | 223 | Too few |
| Traumatic brain injury | $3.3 million | $1.6 million to $6.4 million | 461 | $2.28 million (39) |
| Amputation | $2.98 million | $1.18 million to $7.37 million | 120 | Too few |
| Death | $1.98 million | $1 million to $3.75 million | 690 | $2.01 million (90) |
| Loss of sight or hearing | $1.75 million | $1 million to $5.5 million | 73 | Too few |
| Spinal fusion surgery | $1.73 million | $812,500 to $2.88 million | 171 | $2 million (36) |
| Internal organ injury | $1.5 million | $818,750 to $3.26 million | 216 | $2.6 million (28) |
| Other surgery | $1.4 million | $750,000 to $2.7 million | 629 | $1.12 million (58) |
| Burns | $1.25 million | $575,000 to $3 million | 113 | Too few |
| Any injury that needed surgery | $1 million | $450,000 to $2.25 million | 1,669 | $1 million (184) |
| Psychological injury or PTSD | $1 million | $250,000 to $3.5 million | 125 | $794,150 (86) |
| Herniated disc that needed surgery | $825,000 | $350,000 to $2 million | 121 | $1.95 million (27) |
| Concussion | $775,000 | $376,625 to $1.39 million | 26 | Too few |
| Broken bone | $750,000 | $300,000 to $1.96 million | 557 | $550,000 (55) |
| Broken bone that needed surgery | $750,000 | $375,000 to $1.6 million | 297 | $800,000 (51) |
| Knee, shoulder or other joint surgery | $700,000 | $300,000 to $1.6 million | 505 | $969,366 (64) |
| Scarring or disfigurement | $612,500 | $250,000 to $1.59 million | 86 | $648,616 (30) |
| Herniated disc, surgery not stated | $525,000 | $140,250 to $1.5 million | 130 | $860,000 (23) |
| Sprain, strain or other soft-tissue injury | $475,000 | $120,000 to $1.25 million | 511 | $392,500 (86) |
| Broken bone that didn't need surgery | $400,000 | $160,000 to $537,500 | 23 | Too few |
| Herniated disc that didn't need surgery | $50,000 | $22,500 to $175,000 | 61 | None |
A recovery can name more than one injury, and then it counts under each. All 61 recoveries for a herniated disc that didn't need surgery were published by law firms, and 72% of them by a single firm.
Why surgery changes the number
Surgery is strong evidence that an injury is serious, and it adds medical bills and time off work. That shows in the numbers:
- A herniated disc that needed surgery typically recovered $825,000. One that didn't typically recovered $50,000.
- A broken bone that needed surgery typically recovered $750,000. One that didn't typically recovered $400,000.
The kind of case matters too
The same injury can be worth very different amounts in different kinds of cases. A sprain or strain typically recovered $300,000 in vehicle crash cases but $1.75 million in construction cases, where New York's Scaffold Law makes property owners and contractors responsible for falls caused by missing or unsafe safety equipment. Our case value guides give the numbers for 16 kinds of cases, from car accidents to medical malpractice.
What your own case is worth
The injury sets the range. Where your case falls in it depends on:
- Whether the injury is permanent, and how much it limits your work and daily life.
- Your medical bills and lost pay, now and in the future.
- Who was at fault. If you were partly to blame, your recovery goes down by your share. In most car crash lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026, you can't recover damages if you were more to blame than the people you are suing.
- How much insurance there is. The other side's insurance limit is generally the most you can collect from that insurer.
- After a car crash, whether your injury passes New York's "serious injury" test. Our serious injury guide explains it.
SettleScore's settlement calculator shows what you would keep from a recovery after the lawyer's fee and costs.
How to read these numbers
- Law firms choose which wins to publish, and 90% of the 5,180 recoveries came from firms' own websites, so these figures likely run higher than typical outcomes.
- The amounts are what the case recovered in total. The lawyer's fee, case costs and medical bills that must be paid back come out first.
- The City of New York's payment records rarely describe the injury, so they are mostly not included here.
This article gives general information about New York law and recoveries published by law firms. It is not legal advice. Talk with a New York injury lawyer about your own case.
Sources
- Recoveries: SettleScore's records of New York recoveries that name the injury, as of November 13, 2026: 5,180 recoveries, 90% of them published by law firms and the rest from court, government and press records. Groups with fewer than 20 recoveries aren't shown. Injury figures by kind of case: the same records. See how SettleScore works.
- Scaffold Law: New York Court of Appeals, Blake v Neighborhood Housing Services of New York City (2003).
- Sharing blame: CPLR 1411. The 2026 rule for crash lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026: New York State Department of Financial Services, Insurance Circular Letter No. 3 (2026).


