Skip to main content

What Do I Actually Keep From a New York Injury Settlement?

By Nico SteelePublished · 5 min read

Glasses and a pen on a notebook

The honest answer is that on an ordinary New York injury case with modest medical bills, people tend to walk away with somewhere between half and two-thirds of the settlement figure. The exact number depends on three things, and they get paid in a fixed order.

The order of payment

Money never comes out in a jumble. It comes out in this sequence, and knowing the sequence is most of what you need.

OrderWho gets paidRoughly how much
1Your lawyer's feeUp to one-third, or a sliding scale set by court rule
2Case costsA few hundred dollars up to five figures
3Medical paybacksWhatever Medicare, Medicaid, a hospital, a health plan or workers' comp paid for your care
4YouWhat is left

The fourth line is your take-home amount, and it is the number ads rarely mention.

A worked example

Take a $100,000 car accident settlement with $5,000 of case costs, a one-third fee, and $12,000 that Medicare paid toward your treatment. The fee here is figured by the net method: case costs come off first, and the one-third is taken from what is left.

LineAmount
Settlement$100,000
Case costs−$5,000
Legal fee (one-third of $95,000)−$31,667
Medicare, after its reduction−$7,600
You take home$55,733

That is a real outcome, not a bad one. It is simply not $100,000, and the time to learn that is at the beginning rather than the end.

Why Medicare's number shrank

Medicare gets repaid for treatment related to your injury, but it does not collect the full amount. Federal rules cut its demand in proportion to the legal fee and costs that produced the recovery, on the theory that Medicare benefited from your lawyer's work. In the example above, the fee and costs ($36,667) are about 37% of the settlement, so the $12,000 bill came down by about 37%, to $7,600. The reduction is built into the rules, but somebody has to ask for it.

The other people who may want paying back

  • Medicaid can claim what it spent on your care. It ranks behind your lawyer's fee.
  • Hospitals can file a claim for treating injuries someone else caused, and that also ranks behind the legal fee.
  • Regular health insurance usually cannot take any of your settlement back, because New York's General Obligations Law 5-335 blocks it. Some employer plans that pay claims with the employer's own money can, because federal law can override that rule.
  • Workers' compensation gets repaid out of a recovery against someone other than your employer, reduced by a fair share of the fees and costs that produced it.
  • Most of these amounts are negotiable, and any reduction your lawyer gets goes to you, not the firm.

The bills that are never in the settlement at all

In a car crash, New York's No-Fault coverage pays the first $50,000 of medical bills and lost wages no matter who caused the accident. Those bills are handled on a separate track and are not part of the money your lawyer takes a percentage of. Two practical consequences:

  • Your medical treatment does not come out of your settlement, up to that limit.
  • No-Fault has its own short deadlines. Written notice to the insurer is due within 30 days of the crash, bills within 45 days of treatment, and proof of lost wages within 90 days of the time missed from work. Missing them can cost you benefits unless you can show a good reason for the delay.

What moves your number the most

In rough order of impact:

  • Which fee method your retainer uses. Under the net method, the fee is figured after case costs come off, as in the example. The rules also allow the fee to be figured on the full settlement if the lawyer pays the case costs on its own account. You would then owe nothing for costs if the case were lost, but on a win the lawyer can also take back an amount equal to the costs. In this example that would leave you $54,267 instead of $55,733. SettleScore's calculator starts with that method, and you can switch it. Ask your lawyer what you would take home under each.
  • How hard the firm negotiates the paybacks. This is invisible from the outside and often worth more than a percentage point of fee.
  • Case costs discipline. Experts are sometimes necessary and sometimes not.
  • Whether the case is medical malpractice, which follows a lower fee schedule that starts at 30% of the first $250,000 and drops from there.

The document that proves all of it

When your lawyer receives the settlement money, New York rules require a closing statement: an itemized accounting filed with the court system's administrative office and sent to you. It lists the gross recovery, the fee, each cost and each medical payback.

  • You are entitled to it, and your lawyer must send it to you.
  • Read it against your retainer agreement.
  • Ask about any line you do not recognize. If the answer is unclear, ask for the bill or paperwork behind that line.

Before you sign with anyone

  • Ask whether the fee comes off before or after costs.
  • Ask what happens to the costs if the case is lost.
  • Ask who handles the medical paybacks and whether they negotiate them.
  • Ask when you can expect the closing statement.

A firm should be able to answer all four clearly before you sign.

The recovery calculator can help you see how illustrative fees, costs, and paybacks change the amount you might keep.

This article is general information about New York law, not legal advice for your situation.

Sources: 22 NYCRR 603.25 · 22 NYCRR 691.20 · Judiciary Law 474-a · 42 CFR 411.37 · CMS, Medicare's recovery process · Social Services Law 104-b · Lien Law 189 · Workers' Compensation Law 29 · General Obligations Law 5-335 · Insurance Law 5102 · NYS DFS, No-Fault FAQs

Was this guide helpful?

← Back to Your settlement