Skip to main content

Best Car Accident Lawyers in Staten Island

Ranked by their case results. Firms can't pay to rank higher.

Ranked firms

11 ranked firms

  1. #1 Jacoby & Meyers, LLP

    Typical result $800,000Highest result $11.1 Million

    SettleScore 75 out of 100
  2. #2 Grandelli & Eskenasi

    Typical result $1 MillionHighest result $17.5 Million

    SettleScore 68 out of 100
  3. #3 Shulman & Hill

    Typical result $1 MillionHighest result $5.1 Million

    SettleScore 64 out of 100
  4. #4 D'Agostino & Associates, P.C.

    Typical result $750,000Highest result $2.25 Million

    SettleScore 51 out of 100
  5. #5 Brandon J. Broderick, Personal Injury Attorney at Law

    Typical result $32,500Highest result $1.65 Million

    SettleScore 49 out of 100
  6. #6 Chelli & Bush, Attorneys at Law

    Typical result $365,000Highest result $775,000

    SettleScore 47 out of 100
  7. #7 The Law Office of Timothy M. O'Donovan

    Typical result $488,000Highest result $4.5 Million

    SettleScore 41 out of 100
  8. #8 Ameduri, Galante & Friscia

    Typical result $1.35 MillionHighest result $3.06 Million

    SettleScore 39 out of 100
  9. #9 The Law Firm of Tracy & Stilwell P.C.

    Typical result $816,000Highest result $2.1 Million

    SettleScore 30 out of 100
  10. #10 O'Connor Injury Law

    Typical result $163,000Highest result $6.26 Million

    SettleScore 29 out of 100
  11. #11 The Law Offices of Robert E. Brown, P.C.

    Typical result $100,000Highest result $450,000

    SettleScore 23 out of 100

Frequently asked questions

Can firms pay to rank higher?

No. A firm's plan, advertising and reviews never change its SettleScore or its place in a ranking.

How are these firms ranked?

By SettleScore. It compares how many cases each firm has won, and how large the results are, with other firms' results in the same case type. It uses results firms publish and public court and government records. Open a firm's profile to see each result and where it comes from.

Does a higher rank mean my case will turn out better?

No. A ranking reflects a firm's past results, and every case is different: your injuries, who was at fault and the insurance available all matter.

Why might a firm not appear here?

A firm needs at least 5 results to be ranked. Some experienced firms publish few results, so their work may not show here.