Skip to main content

Hurt on a Construction Site? How Often Workers Win Under New York's Scaffold Law

By Nico SteelePublished · 4 min read

Two construction workers in safety harnesses on scaffolding

If you were hurt on a construction job in New York, two laws can decide much of your case. Here is how often injured workers win under them on appeal, why the results differ so much, and what it means for you.

What winning before trial means

In a construction injury lawsuit, either side can ask the judge to decide who is responsible before any trial. This is called a motion for summary judgment. A judge can rule three ways:

  • The worker wins on liability. The owner and contractor are responsible, and the only question left is how much the injury is worth.
  • The motion is denied. The facts are in dispute, so a jury will decide who is responsible.
  • The claim is dismissed. The judge finds the law doesn't apply to the accident.

The losing side can appeal. SettleScore looked at 945 of those appeal rulings, decided from 2014 to 2026 by New York's Appellate Division.

The two laws

Labor Law § 240(1), the Scaffold Law, requires owners and contractors to protect workers from falls and falling objects, with safe scaffolds, ladders, harnesses, hoists and similar equipment. If they didn't, and that helped cause the injury, they are responsible. The worker's own carelessness doesn't excuse them. But the law covers only those gravity-related accidents, not every injury on a job site.

Labor Law § 241(6) covers other construction dangers, but only when the owner or contractor broke a specific, concrete rule in New York's Industrial Code, the state's construction safety rules. A general rule, such as one that only calls for "proper" or "adequate" equipment, isn't enough. And a worker's own carelessness can reduce the recovery.

How the appeals came out

The chart below shows how often the injured worker won on liability before trial, for each law and in each of the two appeals courts that hear most New York City cases.

Bar chart of the share of appeal rulings in which the injured worker won on liability before trial: Scaffold Law, § 240(1), 49%; Labor Law § 241(6), 12%; First Department, 47%; Second Department, 18%.

By law

LawRulingsWorker won before trialLeft for trialClaim dismissed
§ 240(1): falls from height and falling objects58049%32%19%
§ 241(6): specific safety-code rules36512%48%40%
Both together94535%38%27%

Scaffold Law claims won before trial four times as often as § 241(6) claims. A § 241(6) claim turns on whether a specific safety-code rule applies to the accident, and in 40% of these rulings the court dismissed the claim.

By appeals court

Appeals courtRulingsWorker won before trialLeft for trialClaim dismissed
First Department (Manhattan and the Bronx)54447%35%18%
Second Department (Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Long Island and the lower Hudson Valley)39018%43%39%

The Appellate Division is split into four departments. The First Department hears appeals from Manhattan and the Bronx, and the Second Department from Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Long Island and the lower Hudson Valley. The Third and Fourth Departments had too few rulings to show.

By year

YearRulingsWorker won before trial
20188834%
20198135%
202010232%
202111730%
202212827%
202310034%
202410137%
202510942%
2026 (so far)10343%

Years before 2018 had fewer than 10 rulings each and aren't shown.

What this means if you were hurt

  • Find out which law fits your accident. A fall from a scaffold, ladder or roof, or being hit by a falling object, usually points to the Scaffold Law. Other accidents may fall under § 241(6), if a specific Industrial Code rule was broken, or under general negligence law.
  • You usually sue the owner and the contractor, not your employer. Workers' compensation is generally the only thing you can get from your own employer.
  • Report the accident and keep the evidence. Tell your employer in writing within 30 days, photograph the scaffold, ladder or equipment, and get the names of coworkers who saw it.
  • Know what construction cases recover. Our construction accident guide shows what cases like yours have recovered in New York City.

How we did this

These are Appellate Division decisions from 2014 to 2026 in which a law firm listed on SettleScore was counsel, not every appeal decision on these motions. They are appeals only: trial-court rulings that nobody appealed aren't in published decisions. Each ruling is counted by how it left the worker's claim. No firm is named. The figures are as of November 13, 2026.

This article gives general information about New York law. It is not legal advice. Talk with a New York injury lawyer about your own case.

Sources

Compare Firms Handling Cases Like These

The top-ranked firms by SettleScore on their documented construction accident results. Firms can't pay to rank higher.

  1. #1 Sacks & Sacks, LLP

    ManhattanSettleScore 98 out of 10096 case results

  2. #2 Block O'Toole & Murphy, LLP

    ManhattanSettleScore 97 out of 10083 case results

  3. #3 Zaremba Brown PLLC

    ManhattanSettleScore 97 out of 10097 case results

See the full ranking

Was this guide helpful?

← Back to Your rights