Skip to main content

Published Settlements: How to Read What NYC Injury Firms Publish

By Nico SteelePublished · 5 min read

Cars on a Manhattan street with the Empire State Building ahead

Most injury firms in New York publish results, on a page of large numbers, a rotating banner or a billboard with a figure and a case type. Those numbers are usually true, and they are still one of the easiest things in legal marketing to misread.

Here is how to get real information out of them.

The words are not interchangeable

The termWhat it actually meansWhat to watch for
VerdictWhat a jury awardedCan be reduced on appeal, and is not what anyone received yet
SettlementAn agreed figure, no trialThe most comparable number of the four
JudgmentA court's entered awardMay include interest and may be appealed
"Recovered"Whatever the firm decides it meansCould be a combined total across several plaintiffs or years

A firm advertising a verdict is telling you it tried the case, which is real information. A firm advertising a settlement is telling you what it negotiated. Both are worth knowing. They are not the same accomplishment.

What a published number leaves out

  • It is the gross figure. The legal fee, case costs and medical paybacks all come out before the client sees anything.
  • A verdict can shrink. Appellate courts in New York can reduce an award that "deviates materially from what would be reasonable compensation."
  • Large future damages may be paid over time. When a jury awards more than $250,000 for future damages, New York generally requires the amount above $250,000 to be paid through an annuity, a contract that pays in installments, rather than in one lump sum. A headline number can turn into a stream of payments stretching over many years.
  • Insurance often sets the ceiling. New York only requires a private driver to carry $25,000 per person in bodily injury coverage. A result of $1 million or more usually means the defendant was a business with larger insurance. It does not by itself show the lawyer was better.
  • The firm may not have tried it. New York permits lawyers at different firms to share a fee when the client agrees in writing, so a published result can belong to a case that was referred out.

The average and the typical case are different animals

Public data makes this concrete. In the New York City Comptroller's claims reporting for fiscal 2023, motor vehicle personal injury claims against the City settled for an average of $308,441 and a median of $65,000. The median is the middle figure: half of the claims settled for less and half for more.

Motor vehicle claims against the City, FY 2023Figure
Average settlement$308,441
Median settlement$65,000

Both numbers describe the same pile of cases. The average is pulled upward by a handful of catastrophic results; the median sits closer to what an ordinary crash claim actually produced. Firm advertising shows the large results that pull an average up, not the middle-of-the-range ones, which is why a single published figure tells you so little about your own case.

What the advertising rules require

New York rewrote its lawyer advertising rules effective June 1, 2026. Under the rules of professional conduct as they stand now:

  • Anything a firm says about its services, including past results and comparisons with other lawyers, must not be false or misleading.
  • A true statement can still break that rule if it leaves out a fact you would need to understand it.
  • A firm may not say or suggest it is certified as a specialist unless an approved organization has certified it.
  • Ads that mention past results no longer have to include the line "Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome." Firms may still use it.

Whether or not the line appears, it is true. A published number describes a case that already happened to somebody else, and it does not predict yours.

How to check a number

  • Ask for the case name, county and year. A real result has all three.
  • Ask whether it was a verdict or a settlement, and whether it survived appeal.
  • Ask whether the firm tried the case or referred it, and who handled the trial.
  • Ask whether it was one plaintiff or a group.
  • Look at the firm's results as a group, not just its biggest one. Ten mid-size results in cases like yours tell you more than one enormous result in a case nothing like yours.

The comparison that actually predicts something

Published results are worth comparing when they are:

  • Backed up by a court record or a published report, not just stated by the firm
  • Recent, because a firm's trial bench changes
  • Similar to your case in type and in who the defendant was
  • Typical of the firm's work rather than its single best day

Better questions than "how much have you won?"

  • How many cases like mine have you resolved in the last three years, and what did the range look like?
  • Which of these results did your firm take to verdict, and when was the most recent one?
  • Who at the firm would actually handle mine?
  • What is the weakest part of my case?

Specific answers suggest the firm keeps track of its own record. Vague answers, or a quick return to the single biggest number on the wall, suggest it does not, or that the big number is not typical.

None of this makes published results useless. They are evidence, and they tell you the most when you check them.

Browse published recoveries with those distinctions in mind, and follow the cited firm sources when comparing cases.

This article is general information about New York law, not legal advice for your situation.

Sources: NY Rules of Professional Conduct · Appellate Division joint order amending the advertising rules (2026) · NYSBA, The Amendments to the Advertising Rules · CPLR 5501 · CPLR 5041 · Vehicle and Traffic Law 311 · NYC Comptroller, annual claims reporting

Compare Firms Handling Cases Like These

The top-ranked firms by SettleScore on their documented car accident results. Firms can't pay to rank higher.

  1. #1 Block O'Toole & Murphy, LLP

    ManhattanSettleScore 99 out of 10084 case results

  2. #2 Subin Associates, LLP

    ManhattanSettleScore 98 out of 10064 case results

  3. #3 Torgan Cooper + Aaron

    ManhattanSettleScore 95 out of 10037 case results

See the full ranking

Was this guide helpful?

← Back to Hiring a lawyer