Skip to main content

Sliding Scale or One-Third? The Fee Choice Most New Yorkers Never Make

By Nico SteelePublished · 5 min read

A calculator and a notebook on a desk

Almost every injury retainer in New York offers a flat one-third. Almost every client signs it without knowing a second option sits right beside it in the court rules. On a small case the flat third is the better deal. On anything above $33,000 it is not, and the gap gets wide fast.

New York's Appellate Division caps what an injury lawyer can charge. The cap comes in two shapes, and they apply statewide.

The sliding scaleThe flat one-third
How it works50% of the first $1,000, 40% of the next $2,000, 35% of the next $22,000, then 25% of everything above $25,000One percentage, up to 33⅓%, on the whole recovery
Status in the rulesThe defaultAn option you elect in writing
Best forLarger recoveriesSmaller recoveries
Lawyer can later ask a judge for moreYes, in extraordinary circumstancesNo

The first thing to notice is which one is the default. The sliding scale is the baseline the rules set. The flat third applies only if your retainer says so. It is something you agree to, not something the law imposes.

Where the two cross: $33,000

The scale charges more on the first $25,000 and then 25% on everything above that. The flat third never comes down. Run both across a range of outcomes and the crossover is exact. In the table, "recovery" means the amount the fee is figured on, which under the net method is the settlement minus case costs.

RecoverySliding scaleFlat one-thirdDifference
$10,000$3,750$3,333Flat third saves you $417
$25,000$9,000$8,333Flat third saves you $667
$33,000$11,000$11,000Identical
$50,000$15,250$16,667Scale saves you $1,417
$100,000$27,750$33,333Scale saves you $5,583
$250,000$65,250$83,333Scale saves you $18,083
$500,000$127,750$166,667Scale saves you $38,917
$1,000,000$252,750$333,333Scale saves you $80,583

At a million dollars the sliding scale works out to about 25.3% while the flat third stays at 33.3%. That is a difference of about $80,000.

So why does everyone use the flat third?

A few reasons, and they are not sinister:

  • It is simpler to explain and simpler to bill.
  • On the small and mid-size cases that make up most of a firm's volume, it genuinely pays the firm better.
  • It has been the standard retainer for decades, so it is what the form says.
  • Most clients never ask, so there is no pressure to offer anything else.

No firm is obligated to give you the sliding scale. A busy firm may decline, and that is their right. But the question is fair, it costs you nothing to ask, and how a lawyer answers tells you something about how they will handle the rest of your case.

What the flat third gives up on the lawyer's side

There is a trade running the other way, and it is worth understanding before you push hard.

  • A lawyer working on the sliding scale can apply to a judge for a larger fee if the case turns out to involve extraordinary circumstances.
  • A lawyer who elects the flat third gives that up. The third is the ceiling, whatever happens.

So with the flat third, both sides know the fee can never go above one-third. With the sliding scale, a judge could approve a higher fee in a rare, extraordinary case.

How to actually raise it

You do not need to sound like a lawyer. Try this:

  • "Is this the flat one-third, or the sliding scale under the court rules?"
  • "If my case settles for more than about $33,000, the scale costs me less. Can we use it?"
  • "If we stay with the third, is that firm for the life of the case, including trial?"

That last question matters. In an ordinary injury case, a fee of 40% sits above what the rules permit without a judge's approval. If you are quoted a percentage that climbs once the case reaches trial, ask to see that term in the retainer and ask which rule allows it.

The other number in the same paragraph

Whichever percentage you land on, the retainer also has to describe two ways of figuring the fee, before or after case costs come off, and show which one you chose. Under the net method, case costs come off first, the percentage is figured on what is left, and you repay the costs from the recovery. Under the other method, the percentage is figured on the full settlement, which the rules allow only if the lawyer pays the case costs on its own account. You would then owe nothing for costs if the case were lost, but on a win the lawyer can also take back an amount equal to the costs, so you keep somewhat less. Ask which method your retainer uses and what you would take home under each, in dollars.

The fee percentage is worth one conversation. Your check also depends on how carefully the firm controls case costs and how hard it negotiates your medical paybacks, and firms rarely advertise either one.

Try both fee structures in the recovery calculator to see how a different percentage could affect your illustrative take-home amount.

This article is general information about New York law, not legal advice for your situation.

Sources: 22 NYCRR 603.25 (Manhattan, Bronx) · 22 NYCRR 691.20 (Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island) · 22 NYCRR 806.27 · 22 NYCRR 1015.15 · 22 NYCRR Part 1215

Was this guide helpful?

← Back to Hiring a lawyer