Compare Injury Lawyers by What They've Won, Not What They've Advertised
By Nico SteelePublished · 4 min read

In New York City, the firm with the most ads is not always the one with the best results. Subway ads, radio spots and top search results are paid for. A firm's record comes from the cases it has actually handled, and comparing firms on that record takes about an hour.
Here is a way to compare firms on evidence rather than advertising.
The six-point scorecard
| What to compare | What good looks like | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| Results in cases like yours | Several recent results in your case type, not one huge result in an unrelated one | The firm's published results, and asking directly |
| Trial record | Has tried cases to verdict recently, in your county | Ask when, and against whom |
| Who handles your file | A named lawyer you will actually speak with | Ask at the first meeting |
| Licensing and standing | Currently registered and in good standing | The state court system's public attorney directory |
| Fee terms | Written, specific, and explained without hedging | The retainer, before you sign |
| Communication | A clear answer about how often you will hear from them | Ask, then notice how long they take to call you back |
Why the trial record matters even if you settle
The overwhelming majority of injury cases end in a settlement rather than a verdict, which makes it tempting to conclude that trial experience is irrelevant. The opposite is true.
- Insurance carriers track which firms actually try cases.
- A firm that has never taken a case to verdict has less leverage in negotiation, and the adjusters know it.
- The settlement value of your case is partly a function of what the other side believes will happen if they refuse.
So ask the question directly: when did you last try a case to verdict, and in which county?
What advertising can and cannot tell you
New York's professional conduct rules limit what a firm can claim. Under the advertising rules in effect since June 1, 2026:
- Statements about past results, and comparisons with other lawyers, must not be false or misleading. That includes a true statement that leaves out a fact you would need to understand it.
- A firm cannot say it is certified as a specialist unless an approved organization has certified it.
- Ads that mention results no longer have to say "Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome," though firms may still include it.
None of that makes advertising useless. It makes advertising a starting point for names rather than a ranking. Some of the phone numbers you see belong to marketing companies that sell the call to whichever firm bought that ZIP code.
Free checks worth doing before you sign
- Confirm the license. Every attorney admitted in New York appears in the court system's public directory, with admission date and current registration status.
- Check discipline. Serious misconduct is handled by the Appellate Division's grievance committees and produces published decisions.
- Read the retainer at home, rather than in the office or in a hospital bed.
- Call twice. How a firm treats you before you are a client is the best available preview of how it treats you after.
Questions that produce useful answers
- How many cases like mine has this firm resolved in the last three years, and what was the range, not the peak?
- Will you personally handle my file, or will someone else?
- What is the weakest part of my case?
- Which fee structure is this, the sliding scale or the flat one-third, and does it come off before or after costs?
- If nothing is recovered, what do I owe you?
- If another firm is brought in, does my total fee change?
That last one has a right answer. Lawyers at different firms may divide a fee. The client has to agree in writing after being told how the split works, and the total still has to be reasonable. Bringing in co-counsel should never raise what you pay.
Four things that should slow you down
- A guaranteed number. Nobody can value a case before reading the medical records.
- A fee above New York's limits in an ordinary injury case. A flat fee cannot be more than one-third, and the sliding scale has fixed rates, unless a judge approves more.
- Pressure to sign immediately, especially at a hospital or in the days right after a crash.
- No straight answer about who will handle the file day to day.
What actually moves your outcome
In rough order of importance, the things that change what you end up with:
- Whether the firm finds all the available insurance coverage
- How hard it negotiates your medical paybacks at the end
- Whether it is willing to file suit and try the case if the offer is low
- How disciplined it is about case costs
- And only then, the fee percentage
You can ask about each of these before you sign, and none of them appears in an advertisement. Compare firms on published results you can verify, on trial records you can ask about, and on how clearly they answer a hard question about their own fee.
Use the rankings to compare firms' published evidence, then ask each firm the same questions about who will handle your case.
This article is general information about New York law, not legal advice for your situation.
Sources: NY Rules of Professional Conduct · Appellate Division joint order amending the advertising rules (2026) · NYSBA, The Amendments to the Advertising Rules · NYS Attorney Directory · NYSBA, guide to attorney discipline · 22 NYCRR 603.25 · 22 NYCRR 691.20 · NY Courts, find a lawyer
Compare Firms Handling Cases Like These
The top-ranked firms by SettleScore on their documented case results. Firms can't pay to rank higher.
#1 Block O'Toole & Murphy, LLP
ManhattanSettleScore 99 out of 100284 case results
#2 Torgan Cooper + Aaron
ManhattanSettleScore 97 out of 100140 case results
#3 Kelner & Kelner
ManhattanSettleScore 96 out of 100238 case results


